The Investment Structure: Full Ownership Plus Long-Term Commercial Lease
The standard investment model for classified tourism residences sold to private investors is the acquisition of full ownership of a furnished apartment, coupled with an immediate long-term lease of that apartment to a hotel or para-hotel management company. The investor buys the property, signs a commercial lease with the management company for a minimum of nine years (in practice typically nine to twelve years), and from that point plays no active role in the operation. The management company bears all copropriété charges and furniture maintenance costs during the lease, lets the apartment to tourists on a short-term basis, and pays the investor a contractually agreed rent. At the end of the lease, the investor recovers free use of the property, unless the lease is renewed.
Commercial terms vary significantly between developers. Some contracts provide the investor with a pure investment — no personal use during the lease period, with all economic benefit going to the management company. Others combine a rental income with a limited number of weeks of personal use per year in the investor's apartment or in a comparable apartment within the same group.
Advance of the VAT refund as an immediate financial benefit
In most packages marketed by developers, a portion of the acquisition price is advanced to the investor in the form of a VAT refund advance (see the VAT section below). Additionally, where the investor receives no rent during the lease, the absence of rent corresponds to a rent advance structured as a price reduction: the management company pays the developer the total rents projected for the entire lease at outset; the developer transfers that debt to the management company; and the management company thereafter holds both a debt and a receivable from the investor-owner of equivalent amounts, which are settled by mutual set-off as each rental period falls due.
Classified Tourism Residences: Definition and Classification
A résidence de tourisme is a classified commercial accommodation establishment, operating permanently or seasonally. It consists of one or more individual or collective residential buildings grouped together as a homogeneous unit, comprising furnished residential units and communal areas. The furnished units are offered to a tourist clientele who do not make the residence their domicile, for stays by the day, week, or month. The residence must have a minimum level of shared facilities and services, and must in all cases be managed by a single physical or legal person (C. tourisme Art. D 321-1).
Classification by Atout France
Tourism residences are classified into star categories according to criteria set by Atout France (the French tourism development agency) and approved by ministerial order (C. tourisme Art. D 321-3; Arrêté ECO11835708A du 10 avril 2019). The classification application is made by the operator, accompanied by an inspection certificate from an accredited evaluation body. The classification decision is made by Atout France for a five-year period (C. tourisme Art. L 321-1 and D 321-6). Since 1 January 2022, where a residence has been unable to file a renewal application within the prescribed period, the classification is maintained temporarily provided the operator has initiated the required inspection process.
Letting obligation where held under copropriété
Where a tourism residence is held under the copropriété statute, the règlement de copropriété must expressly provide (C. tourisme Art. D 321-2): a letting obligation of at least 70% of the furnished units for a minimum of nine years (reduced to 55% for residences that have been operating for more than nine years and whose classification has expired, and for unclassified establishments operating for more than nine years that meet the characteristics of a classified tourism residence), with priority reservation rights for copropriétaires; and single-entity management of the entire residence by a person linked to the copropriétaires by a lease or management mandate. Reconverting a classified tourism residence into an ordinary residential building raises significant practical difficulties at the technical, administrative, and legal levels.
The Management Company's Rights: Commercial Lease and Eviction Indemnity
Where the management company provides services in the let premises — which is the norm in classified tourism residences — the lease qualifies as a commercial lease under C. com. Art. L 145-7-1. This has a critical consequence for the investor-landlord: the management company holds statutory commercial lease renewal rights. The lease has a minimum nine-year duration and the management company-tenant cannot exercise the triennial break right that ordinary commercial tenants enjoy. If the landlord refuses renewal, they must pay the management company an eviction indemnity calculated under ordinary commercial lease rules.
This right must be disclosed to investors. Under C. tourisme Art. L 321-3, all marketing documents for a classified tourism residence must explicitly state the existence of the right to an eviction indemnity in the event of non-renewal of the commercial lease, together with the general method for calculating that indemnity. The mandatory wording prescribed by the Arrêté du 23 décembre 2009 must appear in all such documents. The investor must evaluate the potential cost of an eviction indemnity before signing.
Marketing document requirements
Marketing documents for a classified tourism residence must contain information about: the developer and manager (their identity, respective commitments to the investor, the developer's experience in tourism residences, and the number of residences managed by the manager); the financial and fiscal advantages of the investment and the conditions for benefiting from them, including the requirement for the establishment to maintain its tourism classification; the different investment structures available to the acquirer; and the property itself (precise location, transport links, construction standards, management arrangements including copropriété details and charges, and constraints on fitting-out and equipping the private units) (C. tourisme Art. L 321-4; Arrêté ECEI0929483A du 23 décembre 2009).
Annual reporting by the operator
The management company must communicate to all owners, once a year, a report on the preceding year covering: the occupancy rate achieved; significant events; and the amount and movement of the principal income and expenditure items of the residence (C. tourisme Art. L 321-2). Owners who request it may obtain the full exploitation accounts of their residence, detailing occupancy rates, significant events, principal income and expenditure, and a breakdown of variable charges (commissions, linen, cleaning, energy) and fixed charges (staff, maintenance, lease, taxes).
The management company's commercial lease renewal right — and the associated eviction indemnity if renewal is refused — is one of the most financially significant features of this investment structure. The indemnity is calculated under ordinary commercial lease rules and can be substantial. It must be disclosed in all marketing documents (C. tourisme Art. L 321-3), but investors should obtain an independent legal assessment of the likely amount before committing to any acquisition.
The Censi-Bouvard Tax Reduction
The Censi-Bouvard scheme (CGI Art. 199 sexvicies) provided an income tax reduction for individual investors — who must hold LMNP status at the time of acquisition — acquiring furnished units in qualifying service residences and letting them under a nine-year minimum commitment to the operator. No new investments made after 31 December 2022 qualify. Investors who made qualifying acquisitions before that date continue to benefit from the annual tranche of the reduction spread over nine years, with the possibility of carrying forward unused fractions.
Change of operator during the nine-year commitment
Where the operator changes during the letting commitment period, the property must in principle be let to the new operator within one month of the change. A vacancy of up to one year is accepted in certain cases of operator failure — including judicial liquidation, lease termination, or lease assignment — without triggering recapture of the reduction. Investors should document any such vacancy carefully.
VAT on Tourism Residence Rents
When rents are subject to VAT
Accommodation services provided in classified tourism residences are subject to VAT where the residence is intended for tourist accommodation and is let under a lease of at least nine years to an operator who has made a commitment to international tourist promotion (CGI Art. 261 D, 4°-a). This covers the letting by the operator to tourists. The letting by the investor-owner to the management company is also taxable, either under CGI Art. 260 D (which treats indirect lettings whose ultimate destination is furnished letting as tourism letting operations) or under CGI Art. 261 D, 4°-c where the letting is to an operator taxable under Art. 261 D, 4°-a. The tax rate on accommodation supply is 10%.
For para-hotel schemes that do not fall within classified tourism residences, the activity becomes taxable where the letting includes at least three of the four qualifying services provided in conditions comparable to those of a professionally operated hotel establishment: breakfast; regular cleaning of the premises; supply of household linen; and reception, even non-personalised, of guests (CGI Art. 261 D, 4°-b). Student residences and retirement homes may also fall within this category on this basis.
VAT recovery for the investor
Where the letting by the investor to the management company is subject to VAT, the investor-owner can recover the input VAT charged on acquisition of the property and on associated costs. In practice, developer packages are structured to satisfy the conditions for VAT taxability, enabling the investor to recover the VAT paid on the purchase price. Some developers arrange for the investor to purchase at a price net of VAT, with the developer paying the VAT itself on the day of the notarial sale and recovering it subsequently — eliminating the investor's cash-flow exposure. In all cases, if the property is sold within 20 years of acquisition, the investor must repay a proportion of the recovered VAT equal to 1/20th for each complete year remaining in the 20-year period.
Where the investor reserves personal use periods in their apartment during the lease, the value of those periods — the rent the investor would have received if the property had been let normally without the personal-use discount — must be included in the VAT base. This applies even if the investor receives a reduced rent or no rent during their personal-use weeks. The tax base for the investor's letting therefore includes the notional value of any personal-use benefit received.
Income Tax on Rents
BIC or revenus fonciers?
The applicable income tax category depends on the structure of the letting between the investor and the management company. Where the investor lets the premises bare (unfurnished) to the management company — even if the management company then sublets furnished to guests — income is taxed as revenus fonciers, unless the letting reverts to BIC because of the commercial character of the arrangement (for example, where the rent is based on the management company's results, making the landlord a participant in the business). Where the investor lets the property furnished, income falls under BIC, whether the investor qualifies as LMP or LMNP.
In the most common structure for classified tourism residences — where the investor lets furnished to the management company — the BIC regime applies. As LMNP investors under the régime réel, they may deduct actual charges including amortissement of building and furniture (subject to the Censi-Bouvard restriction, under which amortissement is deductible only on the cost base fraction exceeding the Censi-Bouvard base retained for the tax reduction). LMNP deficits are ringfenced against same-nature income with a ten-year carry-forward. LMP deficits are imputable on global income without limit.
Lump-sum advance rents
Where the investor receives all rents in advance in a single lump sum at the start of the lease, the full amount is taxable in the year received — there is no spreading mechanism. This creates a significant tax concentration in the year of receipt, but may be advantageous where the investor has accumulated déficits fonciers from other property income that can be offset in the same year.
CFE and Taxe Foncière
The cotisation foncière des entreprises (CFE) is owed on furnished letting as a professional activity. In the typical tourism residence structure, it is the management company that provides the accommodation service — not the investor-owner, who merely lets to the operator. In principle it is therefore the management company that is the CFE taxpayer. For the bare letting of non-residential premises, CFE applies to the landlord where annual gross receipts exceed €100,000; it is not due below that threshold.
Investor-owners of units in tourism residences are subject to taxe foncière on built properties in the ordinary way. New-build units benefit from a partial exemption: as the Conseil d'État has held, a new-build unit within a tourism residence that is let for short-stay tourism purposes is not a residential building, and the temporary exemption applicable to it covers 40% of the taxable base for the two years following completion (the portion levied for the benefit of intercommunal public establishments — EPCI — remaining due) (CE 24-10-2014 n° 376645).
Multipropriété: The Attribution en Jouissance à Temps Partagé
Holiday residences have long been the most common setting for the attribution en jouissance à temps partagé structure — also known as multipropriété, pluripropriété, propriété spatio-temporelle, or time-sharing. In this structure, the investor does not acquire direct ownership of a property: instead, they acquire shares in a société d'attribution that entitles them to periodic use of a furnished unit. The investor is a shareholder and a periodic user — not a property owner.
Liquidity risk
Shares in a société d'attribution are difficult to resell to third parties or other members. Exit from the company requires unanimous consent of all shareholders — though a court may authorise withdrawal for legitimate reasons including receipt of minimum social benefits, a salary below the SMIC, or inability to use the property due to closure or inaccessibility of the residence. Withdrawal is a matter of right where shares were received by inheritance less than two years before the withdrawal request.
Tax regime of the société d'attribution
The société d'attribution is subject to corporation tax (IS), both when incorporated as a company of capital and when incorporated as a civil company (given its commercial activity: property management, service provision, and provision of furnished premises to members). The fiscal transparency regime of C. civ. Art. 1655 ter does not apply, as Loi 86-18 du 6 janvier 1986 Art. 35 expressly excludes these companies.
A special regime under CGI Art. 239 octies applied to IS-subject société d'attribution that transferred the use of furnished premises to their members without charge. Under this regime, the net value of the benefit in kind — calculated as the difference between the rent the company could have charged if it had let the property and the amounts paid by the member for expenses not chargeable to them as user — was excluded from the company's taxable profit and did not constitute a distributed dividend. This regime applied to benefits in kind conferred during accounting periods opened until 31 December 2023. Individual shareholders holding shares as private persons were not taxable on the benefit in kind — they were placed in the same position as if they had been direct owner-occupiers. This exemption did not apply to corporate shareholders subject to IS or to individual shareholders taxable under BIC.
For VAT, société d'attribution companies are exempt on essential services provided to members in exchange for strict reimbursement of their share of common expenses, under CGI Art. 261 A. No surplus of receipts over costs is permitted; if a surplus arises, the entire amount received becomes taxable — not just the surplus.
Share transfers
Transfers of shares in a société d'attribution whose purpose is to transfer furnished premises to members in time-sharing are subject to the capital gains on securities and social rights regime (CGI Art. 150-0 A et seq.) for income tax purposes. For transfer duties and VAT, CGI Art. 728 and 257, I-1-3° apply: where the transferor is a taxable person and the shares give effective or legal entitlement to the attribution in ownership or use of a building not completed for more than five years, the transfer is subject to VAT; otherwise, ordinary real estate transfer duties apply. For transfers by a private individual outside any economic activity, no VAT applies.
The greatest caution is warranted before investing in a société d'attribution. The shares are difficult to resell and exit requires unanimous shareholder consent. Vacation periods can in some cases be exchanged through international exchange bureaux, but no specific exchange is guaranteed. This structure should be assessed as a lifestyle purchase with fiscal consequences — not as a conventional property investment.
Whether you are assessing the commercial lease terms of a classified tourism residence, reviewing your Censi-Bouvard position, or evaluating the VAT recovery mechanics on a new acquisition, our guides cover the complete French framework.
Book a ConsultationThis article is based on applicable French legislation as cited. The Censi-Bouvard scheme (CGI Art. 199 sexvicies) is confirmed closed to new investments after 31 December 2022; the parameters described apply to qualifying investments made before that date. The special IS regime for société d'attribution under CGI Art. 239 octies applied to accounting periods opened until 31 December 2023 — the position for subsequent periods should be verified. VAT mechanics are complex and depend on the specific structure of each operation; specialist VAT advice should be obtained before any acquisition. References are correct to the best of the author's knowledge as of the date of publication.
Get Advice
Contracting with a French Party?
We advise sellers and buyers on French sales law, warranties, retention of title and cross-border terms. Speak to our team.
Get Legal Advice
Key Legal References
Classified tourism residence: definition as a classified commercial accommodation establishment; furnished units for tourist clientele who do not make the residence their domicile; minimum shared facilities; single management entity.
Copropriété rules for classified tourism residences: règlement de copropriété must provide a letting obligation of at least 70% of furnished units for a minimum of 9 years (reduced to 55% for residences operating for more than 9 years whose classification has expired); single-entity management by lease or mandate.
Classification of tourism residences by Atout France: star categories according to criteria approved by ministerial order; classification for a 5-year period; application made by operator with inspection certificate from accredited evaluation body.
Annual operator reporting obligation: management company must communicate to all owners once a year a report covering the occupancy rate achieved, significant events, and the principal income and expenditure items. Full exploitation accounts available on request.
Mandatory disclosure in marketing documents of the management company’s right to an eviction indemnity in the event of non-renewal of the commercial lease, together with the general method for calculating that indemnity. Mandatory wording prescribed by Arrêté ECEI0929483A du 23 décembre 2009.
Marketing document requirements for a classified tourism residence: developer and manager identity and commitments; financial and fiscal advantages and conditions; investment structures available; precise location, construction standards, management arrangements, and constraints on fitting-out.
Commercial lease for tourism residence operators: lease qualifies as a commercial lease where the operator provides services in the let premises; minimum 9-year duration; no triennial break right for the management company-tenant; right to renewal and, if refused, eviction indemnity under ordinary commercial lease rules.
Censi-Bouvard income tax reduction: 11% (from 2012), 25% (2009–2010), 18% (2011) on qualifying furnished unit acquisitions in service residences; base €300,000/year; spread over 9 years (1/9th p.a.); carry-forward 6 years; LMNP status required; BIC income throughout 9-year commitment; closed to new investments after 31 December 2022. Eligible residences: EHPAD, disabled adult residences, senior/disabled service residences, salaried family hosting groupings, student service residences, long-stay medical establishments.
VAT on classified tourism residence rents at 10%: applicable where the residence is intended for tourist accommodation and let under a lease of at least 9 years to an operator who has made a commitment to international tourist promotion.
Para-hôtellerie VAT: letting becomes taxable where the operator provides at least 3 of 4 qualifying hotel services (breakfast; regular cleaning; supply of household linen; reception of guests) in conditions comparable to a professionally operated hotel establishment.
Investor-owner letting to management company taxable where the management company is itself taxable under CGI Art. 261 D, 4°-a: the investor’s letting follows the taxable character of the ultimate furnished letting operation.
New-build unit within a tourism residence let for short-stay tourism purposes is not a residential building: the temporary taxe foncière exemption covers 40% of the taxable base for the two years following completion (the EPCI portion remaining due).
Société d’attribution timeshare framework (multipropriété): shares give right to periodic use of furnished unit, not direct property ownership; IS-taxable; excluded from CGI Art. 1655 ter fiscal transparency by Loi 86-18 du 6 janvier 1986 Art. 35; exit requires unanimous shareholder consent.
Special IS regime for société d’attribution: net benefit-in-kind (difference between market rent and member’s cost reimbursement) excluded from company’s taxable profit and not treated as distributed dividend. Applied to accounting periods opened until 31 December 2023. Not available where company has more than 10% revenue-generating transactions with third parties. Individual members not taxable on the benefit in kind.
VAT exemption for société d’attribution on essential services provided to members in exchange for strict reimbursement of their share of common expenses. No surplus permitted; if a surplus arises, the entire amount received becomes taxable.
Transfer of shares in a société d’attribution: capital gains on securities regime (CGI Art. 150-0 A) for income tax. Transfer duties or VAT depending on whether the transferor is a taxable person and on the age of the building (CGI Art. 728 and 257, I-1-3°).
